Dino extinction researcher committed research misconduct —but not fraud, university report finds
Paleontologist Robert DePalma, whose claim that the asteroid that killed the dinosaurs struck in springtime drew accusations of fraud, is guilty of “several counts of poor research practice” that “constitute research misconduct,” according to an investigation. The report by the University of Manchester, which it shared with
Science
, says DePalma did not fabricate data, but notes he was unable to say where the key isotope data underlying
his 2021 paper in
Scientific Reports
were produced.
“I’m happy the university acknowledged poor research practices [and] misconduct,” says paleontologist and Ph.D. student Melanie During. “That’s a big win.” She and her adviser, paleontologist Per Ahlberg of Uppsala University, had filed the fraud complaint, and she continues to think
Scientific Reports
should retract DePalma’s paper. “Nonscientific information has been published as scientific information, and it is still out there,” she says.
DePalma emphasizes the university, where he is now a Ph.D. student, cleared him of fabricating data. He says that what he calls errors in “record-keeping and data presentation … collectively were labeled as a form of misconduct of a negligent sense, which is fuel for self-improvement and positive adjustment.”
A representative for Springer Nature Group, which publishes
Scientific Reports
, told
Science
they were “considering our next steps.” T...
Source: ScienceNOW - Category: Science Source Type: news
More News: Diets | Fish | Laboratory Medicine | Medical Ethics | Nutrition | Science | Students | Universities & Medical Training