The Mid-Life Dip in Well-Being: a Critique

AbstractA number of studies —including our own—find a mid-life dip in well-being. Yet several papers in the psychology literature claim that the evidence of a U-shape is"overblown" and if there is such a thing that any such decline is"trivial". Others have claimed that the evidence of a U-shape"is not as robust and generalizable as is often assumed," or simply"wrong." We identify 409 studies, mostly published in peer reviewed journals that find U-shapes that these researchers apparently were unaware of. We use data for Europe from the Eurobarometer Surveys (EB), 1980 –2019; the Gallup World Poll (GWP), 2005–2019 and the UK's Annual Population Survey, 2016–2019 and the Census Bureau's Household Pulse Survey of August 2021, to examine U-shapes in age in well-being. We find remarkably strong and consistent evidence across countries of statistically significan t and non-trivial U-shapes in age with and without socio-economic controls. We show that studies cited by psychologists claiming there are no U-shapes are in error; we reexamine their data and find differently. The effects of the mid-life dip we find are comparable to major life events such as losin g a spouse or becoming unemployed. This decline is comparable to half of the unprecedented fall in well-being observed in the UK in 2020 and 2021, during the Covid19 pandemic and lockdown, which is hardly “inconsequential” as claimed.
Source: Social Indicators Research - Category: International Medicine & Public Health Source Type: research