Government Businesses Can ' t Simply Take Over Property They ' ve Been Unable to Buy

For many years, Violet Dock Port had owned and operated a docking facility that stretched along a mile of the Mississippi River in St. Bernard Parish, Louisiana. As a private business, Violet was in economic competition with the local Port Authority, which also owns and operates riverfront property.In 2007, the Port Authority took an interest in Violet ’s land and tried to negotiate a purchase, but those negotiations failed. If this had been a normal negotiation between two private market participants, the Port Authority would have had only two options at that point: improve its offer or walk away. But instead it decided to appeal to its status as a public agency and claim that it required Violet’s land for “public use.” Invoking Louisiana’s eminent domain power to complete the deal by force, the Port Authority took over Violet’s business and eliminated its competition.Violet has challenged this taking in state court, and the case has now reached the Louisiana Supreme Court. Cato has joined the National Federation of Independent Business Small Business Legal Center, Southeastern Legal Foundation, and Louisiana Association of Business and Industry on anamicus brief urging the state supreme court to strike down this taking under both the federal and Louisiana constitutions. Under both constitutions, private property can only be taken by eminent domain if it is for a true public use. But a taking that is solely for the purpose of eliminating private competition is no...
Source: Cato-at-liberty - Category: American Health Authors: Source Type: blogs