25th Amendment Still Not the Right Response to a Mentally Ill Trump

By MIKE MAGEE On May 16, 2017 New York Times conservative columnist, Russ Douthat, wrote “The 25th Amendment Solution for Removing Trump.”  That column was the starting point for a Spring course I taught on the 25th Amendment at the President’s College in Hartford, CT. I will not summarize the entire course here, but would like to emphasize four points: The American public was adequately warned (now 7 years ago) of the risk that Trump represented to our nation and our democracy. Douthat’s piece triggered a journalistic debate which I summarize below with four slides drawn from my lectures. Had Pence and the cabinet chosen to activate the 25th Amendment, as it is written, Trump would have had the right to appeal “his inability”, forcing the Congress to decide whether there was cause to remove the President. Judging from the later impeachment of Trump in the House, but failure to convict in the Senate, it is unlikely a courageous Pence and Cabinet would have been backed by their own party. Let’s look at four archived slides from the 2017 lecture, and then discuss our current options in the case of 2024 Trump against Democracy.  Slide 1. Russ Douthat         Slide 2. Jamal Greene (in response)         Slide 3. Dahlia Lithwick (in response in SLATE)         Slide 4. The 25th Amendment  In 2017, Scott Bomboy, chief of the National Constitution Center, wrote: ...
Source: The Health Care Blog - Category: Consumer Health News Authors: Tags: Health Policy 25th Amendment Mike Magee Trump Source Type: blogs