Review and further developments in statistical corrections for Winner ’s Curse in genetic association studies

by Amanda Forde, Gibran Hemani, John Ferguson

Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) are commonly used to identify genomic variants that are associated with complex traits, and estimate the magnitude of this association for each variant. However, it has been widely observed that the association estimates of variants tend to be lower in a replication study than in the study that discovered those associations. A phenomenon known asWinner ’s Curse is responsible for this upward bias present in association estimates of significant variants in the discovery study. We review existingWinner ’s Curse correction methods which require only GWAS summary statistics in order to make adjustments. In addition, we propose modifications to improve existing methods and propose a novel approach which uses the parametric bootstrap. We evaluate and compare methods, first using a wide variety of simulated data sets and then, using real data sets for three different traits. The metric, estimated mean squared error (MSE) over significant SNPs, was primarily used for method assessment. Our results indicate that widely used conditional likelihood based methods tend to perform poorly. The other considered methods behave much more similarly, with our proposed bootstrap method demonstrating very competitive performance. To complement this review, we have developed an R package, ‘winnerscurse’ which can be used to implement these variousWinner ’s Curse adjustment methods to GWAS summary statist...

Source: PLoS Genetics - September 18, 2023 Category: Genetics & Stem Cells Authors: Amanda Forde Source Type: research