Excellence in medical training: developing talent —not sorting it

AbstractMany medical schools have reconsidered or eliminated clerkship grades and honor society memberships. National testing organizations announced plans to eliminate numerical scoring for the United States Medical Licensing Examination Step  1 in favor of pass/fail results. These changes have led some faculty to wonder: “How will we recognize and reward excellence?” Excellence in undergraduate medical education has long been defined by high grades, top test scores, honor society memberships, and publication records. However, this model of learner excellence is misaligned with how students learn or what society values. This accolade-driven view of excellence is perpetuated by assessments that are based on gestalt impressions influenced by similarity between evaluators and students, and assessments that are often restricted to a limited number of traditional skill domains. To achieve a new model of learner excellence that values the trainee’s achievement, growth, and responsiveness to feedback across multiple domains, we must envision a new model of teacher excellence. Such teachers would have a growth mindset towa rd assessing competencies and learning new competencies. Actualizing true learner excellence will require teachers to change from evaluators who conduct assessmentsof learning to coaches who do assessmentfor learning. Schools will also need to establish policies and structures that foster a  culture that supports this change. In this new paradigm, a t...
Source: Perspectives on Medical Education - Category: Universities & Medical Training Source Type: research