Likelihood ratios for changepoints in categorical event data with applications in digital forensics

J Forensic Sci. 2024 Apr 1. doi: 10.1111/1556-4029.15512. Online ahead of print.ABSTRACTWe investigate likelihood ratio models motivated by digital forensics problems involving time-stamped user-generated event data from a device or account. Of specific interest are scenarios where the data may have been generated by a single individual (the device/account owner) or by two different individuals (the device/account owner and someone else), such as instances in which an account was hacked or a device was stolen before being associated with a crime. Existing likelihood ratio methods in this context require that a precise time is specified at which the device or account is purported to have changed hands (the changepoint)-this is the known changepoint likelihood ratio model. In this paper, we develop a likelihood ratio model that instead accommodates uncertainty in the changepoint using Bayesian techniques, that is, an unknown changepoint likelihood ratio model. We show that the likelihood ratio in this case can be calculated in closed form as an expression that is straightforward to compute. In experiments with simulated changepoints using real-world data sets, the results demonstrate that the unknown changepoint model attains comparable performance to the known changepoint model that uses a perfectly specified changepoint, and considerably outperforms the known changepoint model that uses a misspecified changepoint, illustrating the benefit of capturing uncertainty in the chang...

Source: Journal of Forensic Sciences - April 1, 2024 Category: Forensic Medicine Authors: Rachel Longjohn Padhraic Smyth Source Type: research