What makes one a "superstar" or "top" applicant?

1. MCAT of 520+ and GPA of 3.97+? 2. Curing cancer? 3. Huge donor parents? 4. Heisman level athlete? 5. 2+ pubs? 6. Nontrad medical experience? Just trying to understand what would each of the experts use as a definition for a superstar / top applicant
Source: Student Doctor Network - Category: Universities & Medical Training Authors: Tags: Pre-Medical - MD Source Type: forums