Refutation texts and argumentation for conceptual change: A winning or a redundant combination?

Publication date: February 2020Source: Learning and Instruction, Volume 65Author(s): Christa S.C. Asterhan, Maya S. ResnickAbstractEffective instruction for conceptual change should aim to reduce the interference of irrelevant knowledge structures, as well as to improve sense-making of counterintuitive scientific notions. Refutation texts are designed to support such processes, yet evidence for its effect on individual conceptual change of robust, complex misconceptions has not been equivocal. In the present work, we examine whether effects of refutation text reading on conceptual change in biological evolution can be augmented with subsequent peer argumentation activities. Hundred undergraduates read a refutation text followed by either peer argumentation on erroneous worked-out solutions or by standard, individual problem solving. Control group subjects read an expository text followed by individual problem solving. Results showed strong effects for the refutation text. Surprisingly, subsequent peer argumentation did not further improve learning gains after refutation text reading. Dialogue protocols analyses showed that gaining dyads were more likely to be symmetrical and to discuss core conceptual principles.
Source: Learning and Instruction - Category: Psychiatry & Psychology Source Type: research

Related Links:

Called Winship at Midtown, the nearly $500 million building will consolidate cancer services and improve a patient's experience.
Source: bizjournals.com Health Care:Pharmaceuticals headlines - Category: Pharmaceuticals Authors: Source Type: news
Abstract Human papillomaviruses (HPV) are small, double-stranded DNA viruses that cause cervical cancer, the second most lethal cancer among women in the world. Currently, two vaccines are on the market for preventing HPV-caused cervical cancers and warts. Both are virus-like particle (VLP)-based vaccines. However, these vaccines have limitations; they are costly, have an invasive route of administration, require trained personnel to administer, need cold chain storage to preserve them, and most of all, they are preventive vaccines that do not have curative effects. Therefore, it is necessary to develop therapeuti...
Source: J Pharm Pharm Sci - Category: Drugs & Pharmacology Authors: Tags: J Pharm Pharm Sci Source Type: research
No abstract available
Source: Lippincott's Bone and Joint Newsletter - Category: Orthopaedics Tags: CME Article Source Type: news
No abstract available
Source: Lippincott's Bone and Joint Newsletter - Category: Orthopaedics Tags: CME Article Source Type: news
No abstract available
Source: Lippincott's Bone and Joint Newsletter - Category: Orthopaedics Tags: Perspective Source Type: news
No abstract available
Source: Lippincott's Bone and Joint Newsletter - Category: Orthopaedics Tags: Trends and Innovations Source Type: news
No abstract available
Source: Lippincott's Bone and Joint Newsletter - Category: Orthopaedics Tags: Snapshot Source Type: news
No abstract available
Source: Lippincott's Bone and Joint Newsletter - Category: Orthopaedics Tags: Best of the Rest Source Type: news
No abstract available
Source: Lippincott's Bone and Joint Newsletter - Category: Orthopaedics Tags: CME Quiz Source Type: news
No abstract available
Source: Lippincott's Bone and Joint Newsletter - Category: Orthopaedics Tags: Bone and Joint in Brief Source Type: news
More News: Learning | Psychology | Universities & Medical Training