Clinical Controversies: Proton Therapy for Pediatric Tumors

Despite the claim in the published literature, the introduction of proton therapy for children is not analogous to the evolution of conformal photon irradiation relying on the understanding of the impact of altered dose distributions. The differences in radiobiological effect when comparing photons with protons mean that we are comparing a known entity with an unknown entity: the dose-volume histogram for proton therapy might mean something substantially different from the dose-volume histogram for photon therapy. The multifaceted difference between the 2 modalities supports the argument for careful evaluation, follow-up, and clinical trials with adverse event monitoring when using proton therapy in children. We review the current data on the outcome of proton therapy in a range of pediatric tumors and compare them with the often excellent results of photon therapy in the setting of multidisciplinary management of childhood cancer. It is hoped that the apparent dosimetric advantage of proton therapy over photons will lead to improved indications for therapy, disease control, and functional outcomes. Although physical dose distribution is of clear importance, the multimodality management of children by an expert pediatric oncology team and the availability of ancillary measures that improve the quality of treatment delivery may be more important than the actual beam. In addition, current estimates of the benefit of proton therapy over photon therapy based on toxicity reduction...
Source: Seminars in Radiation Oncology - Category: Cancer & Oncology Authors: Source Type: research