The Ethics of Keeping Alfie Alive
By SAURABH JHA
Of my time arguing with doctors, 30 % is spent convincing British doctors that their American counterparts aren’t idiots, 30 % convincing American doctors that British doctors aren’t idiots, and 40 % convincing both that I’m not an idiot.
A British doctor once earnestly asked whether American physicians carry credit card reading machines inside their white coats. Myths about the NHS can be equally comical. British doctors don’t prostate every morning in deference to the NHS, like the citizens of Oceania sang to Big Brother in Orwell’s dystopia. Nor, in their daily rounds, do they calculate opportunity costs for keeping patients alive on ventilators.
Conversations such as this are vanishingly rare.
Administrator: “It’s costing an arm and leg keeping this sick baby alive – to balance the annual budget we need to stop dialyzing a granny.”
ICU doctor: “We’ll have to send poor Ethel to her grave. That’s a shame. She was beginning to grow on me.”
Health Ethicist: “Wait, let me check with National Institute of Clinical Excellence, the rationing experts, who should be relieved of intensive care first. Perhaps it should be Winston, not Ethel – because Winston is an alcoholic. We need to make rationing scientific and fair.”
For the most parts, doctors in both systems do their best for their patients – the constraints of biology play a greater role in influencing physician decisions than the economics of fee-for-service or capitation. Th...
Source: The Health Care Blog - Category: Consumer Health News Authors: at RogueRad Tags: OP-ED Uncategorized AlfieEvans Source Type: blogs
More News: African Health | Alcoholism | American Health | Autism | Babies | Back Pain | Biology | Blogging | Brain | Brain Cancers | Cancer | Cancer & Oncology | Cancer Vaccines | Cardiology | Cerebellum | Cerebral Palsy | Child Development | Children | Cough | CT Scan | Disability | Economics | Epilepsy | Esophagus Cancer | Eyes | Fish | Gastroenterology | Germany Health | Headache | Health | Health Management | Heart | Hemorrhagic Stroke | Hypermetropia (long sighted) | Intensive Care | Italy Health | Legislation | Liver Transplant | Malaria | Malaria Vaccine | Medical Ethics | Men | Meningitis | Meningitis Vaccine | Morphine | Neurology | Neuroscience | Neurosurgery | Obama | Pain | Pain Management | Palliative | Palliative Care | Parenteral Nutrition | Pediatrics | PET Scan | Pneomococcal Vaccine | Pneumonia | Poisoning | Politics | Potassium | Prostate Cancer | Radiography | Radiology | Reflex Sympathetic Dystrophy | Respiratory Medicine | Science | Sodium | Spain Health | Sports Medicine | Stroke | Students | Study | Switzerland Health | Tetanus | Tetanus Vaccine | Tracheostomy | Trump | Tuberculosis | UK Health | Universities & Medical Training | USA Health | Vaccines | Weight Loss | X-Ray